Jump to content


Photo

Talk Me Down! re: Veritas Press


  • Please log in to reply
32 replies to this topic

#1 Raina3

    Homeschooling in the UP

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 1,415 posts

Posted 23 May 2012 - 08:53 AM

I love Sonlight. We're having a great time going (slowly) though Core F right now. But yesterday I received a catalog from Veritas Press for some reason, and . . . wow. I was impressed.

Yes, I'll admit that the colorful pages, the wonderful book descriptions, and the way it was all laid out turned my eye. :) But also, it really does look similar to Sonlight, with many of the books being the same, although used in a different order.

If it's not broken, don't fix it, right? I know I should stick with Sonlight because it works well for us. But still . . .

Have any of you used Veritas Press? Is it close to the Sonlight way or am I way off?
Raina ~
wife to my singer, and mom to:

DS 12 (7th) ~ Core G, SL science G, Teaching Textbooks, Growing with Grammar, IEW, AAS, Typing Instructor Platinum
DD 4 (Preschool) ~ Core P3/4
DD 2 (fun) ~ books, singing, books, dolls, and more books
DS 1 (mischief) ~ everything, everyone, everywhere, all the time

#2 Rockhopper

    On Whatsoever Rock I Hop, I Will Be Content

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 4,080 posts

Posted 23 May 2012 - 09:14 AM

I sometimes get Veritas Press envy too. It all looks so good, so rigorous, so challenging, so rewarding....

But here's the thing I keep coming back to when I get tempted: yes, it's rigorous and challenging and (perhaps) academically superior to Sonlight. But Sonlight schedules "Mara: Daughter of the Nile" for Core G -- aimed at about 6th - 8th graders. Veritas Press has it listed in their second grade offerings.

Yes, my 7 year old could listen to me reading that book. And I could feel proud of myself for pushing her and having her "complete" such a challenging read-aloud. But for what purpose?

A. Much of the material is not appropriate for her at her age (and I say this with it being one of my very favorite books of all and a cherished memory from my childhood - but more at the Core G age than the Core B age!). It's got too many mature themes and scenes.

B. Even leaving that aside, she just wouldn't get that much out of it. All the political intrigue, etc.--- it's just too advanced developmentally for her. She wouldn't get the nuances at all, even if she understood the words.

I frequently add books to our Sonlight cores, and sometimes I use the Veritas Press catalog for ideas. Sometimes the books I add are more challenging, more demanding -- it depends on the child, his/her maturity, the topic.

But in general I trust Sonlight's selections to present new ideas to my kids, develop their listening and reading vocabulary, their comprehension and understanding -- but at in age-appropriate way. Veritas Press may challenge (or push!) but I think a lot of their titles "challenge" in a way that is more about the parent getting to feel rigorous than the child gaining meaningful knowledge.

Edited by Rockhopper, 23 May 2012 - 09:15 AM.

Debra, settling in to a new place yet again, working through 2014-2015 with DS (15), DD (10), DD (4) -- and DH (of 22 years), of course!

 

CONNECTING with family, friends - old and new, IRL and online, and my mostly-dormant interest in photography

 

JOIN US at a museum in downtown DC every Thursday

 

DS: LoF Geometry, LLfLOTR, Spectrum Chemistry, Ancient Roman History, Mounce's Graded Reader of Biblical Greek, Landry Academy Pre-Law

DD: TT, CLE English, A Child's Geography and RSO E&S, American History: E Readers & RAs, Notgrass AtB, American Girl Book & Field Trip Club

Junior Rockhoppers
Uploaded 03 Jan 2015 - 23:43

 

 

20182463.png


#3 ByGrace3

    Registered User

  • Registered Users
  • Pip
  • 13 posts

Posted 23 May 2012 - 09:30 AM

I sometimes get Veritas Press envy too. It all looks so good, so rigorous, so challenging, so rewarding....

But here's the thing I keep coming back to when I get tempted: yes, it's rigorous and challenging and (perhaps) academically superior to Sonlight. But Sonlight schedules "Mara: Daughter of the Nile" for Core G -- aimed at about 6th - 8th graders. Veritas Press has it listed in their second grade offerings.

Yes, my 7 year old could listen to me reading that book. And I could feel proud of myself for pushing her and having her "complete" such a challenging read-aloud. But for what purpose?

A. Much of the material is not appropriate for her at her age (and I say this with it being one of my very favorite books of all and a cherished memory from my childhood - but more at the Core G age than the Core B age!). It's got too many mature themes and scenes.

B. Even leaving that aside, she just wouldn't get that much out of it. All the political intrigue, etc.--- it's just too advanced developmentally for her. She wouldn't get the nuances at all, even if she understood the words.

I frequently add books to our Sonlight cores, and sometimes I use the Veritas Press catalog for ideas. Sometimes the books I add are more challenging, more demanding -- it depends on the child, his/her maturity, the topic.

But in general I trust Sonlight's selections to present new ideas to my kids, develop their listening and reading vocabulary, their comprehension and understanding -- but at in age-appropriate way. Veritas Press may challenge (or push!) but I think a lot of their titles "challenge" in a way that is more about the parent getting to feel rigorous than the child gaining meaningful knowledge.


This is the exact reason I do not use VP as my spine, but add VP books to SL. The VP selections are wonderful, and will be even more wonderful for early logic stage. Many of the books have very mature themes and are idle school or even high school level, especially many of the spines. By adding VP cards, historical fiction books, and even activities, I can add to the "rigor" or challenge of SL and make it fit my child. Keeping in mind, we are in the younger cores, so I have no idea what it would look like to add to the older cores, I know there is already a lot there.

#4 gratefulk

    just keep swimming...

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 2,852 posts
  • LocationBeautiful PNW

Posted 23 May 2012 - 10:22 AM

I need talking down, too, apparently. I knew the elementary years of Veritas Press were not for us, but I am seriously considering Omnibus for ds's seventh grade the year after next. But, this is doing you no good at all since I don't have any actual experience with it. :)

#5 Lightly Salted

    Associate of Learning

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 6,963 posts
  • LocationKentucky

Posted 23 May 2012 - 10:38 AM

I need talking down, too, apparently. I knew the elementary years of Veritas Press were not for us, but I am seriously considering Omnibus for ds's seventh grade the year after next. But, this is doing you no good at all since I don't have any actual experience with it. :)


This is me, too; I can see myself tempted to use it at the middle or high school level; I loved seeing the photo and description of each book!
Amy & DH ~ DD (12) DS (10) ~ Core E
.

#6 texasmomtothree

    Registered User, after 30 days

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 2,086 posts

Posted 23 May 2012 - 10:41 AM

This is me, too; I can see myself tempted to use it at the middle or high school level; I loved seeing the photo and description of each book!


Oh my goodness! I hadn't thought about that but I think that was why I actually sat and studied Veritas catalog this year and really never have in the past! I finally get to see the books and book descriptions! I definitely spent more time reading that catalog than Sonlights's this year....

Michelle
2014-2015 School Year
ds (15) : Core 300, Conceptual Chemistry, TT Algebra 2/Geometry, Intro. to Programming, Spanish I
dd (13) : Core H, IEW Medieval History, Apologia Physical Science, TT Pre-Algebra, AAS 7
ds (10): Core E, IEW SWI-A, TT 4, AAS 4, Science in the Ancient World

            20173920.png


#7 Dinsfamily

    Figuring this stuff out...

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 1,704 posts
  • LocationTexas

Posted 23 May 2012 - 10:42 AM

I need talking down, too, apparently. I knew the elementary years of Veritas Press were not for us, but I am seriously considering Omnibus for ds's seventh grade the year after next. But, this is doing you no good at all since I don't have any actual experience with it. :)


I'm considering this too. Omnibus looks really good, but I don't want my dc to miss some great SL cores, either.
  • ptal04 likes this

Taira

Rangling 4 rambunctious boys:
D-Man (9yo-4th Grade): Core D with Adv Readers
Sweet-C (7yo-2nd Grade): Core B with Grade 3 Readers
J-Monster (5yo- Kindergarten): P4/5
Baby-S (2.5yo): Board books


Blogging about it occasionally at: What Are We Learning?

Posted Image


#8 Lightly Salted

    Associate of Learning

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 6,963 posts
  • LocationKentucky

Posted 23 May 2012 - 10:45 AM

I definitely spent more time reading that catalog than Sonlights's this year....


Me too!
Amy & DH ~ DD (12) DS (10) ~ Core E
.

#9 my cup of tea & me

    Finding my happy pace!

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 4,057 posts

Posted 23 May 2012 - 10:57 AM

I love Sonlight. We're having a great time going (slowly) though Core F right now. But yesterday I received a catalog from Veritas Press for some reason, and . . . wow. I was impressed.

Yes, I'll admit that the colorful pages, the wonderful book descriptions, and the way it was all laid out turned my eye. :) But also, it really does look similar to Sonlight, with many of the books being the same, although used in a different order.

If it's not broken, don't fix it, right? I know I should stick with Sonlight because it works well for us. But still . . .

Have any of you used Veritas Press? Is it close to the Sonlight way or am I way off?

This is me, too; I can see myself tempted to use it at the middle or high school level; I loved seeing the photo and description of each book!

Oh my goodness! I hadn't thought about that but I think that was why I actually sat and studied Veritas catalog this year and really never have in the past! I finally get to see the books and book descriptions! I definitely spent more time reading that catalog than Sonlights's this year....


Hmmmm....I see a theme here. Ladies, didn't you get "word" that book descriptions aren't helpful or appealing to homeschoolers who are choosing curriculum? B)

I *think* I actually got that catalog in the mail this week, but I haven't sorted mail in a few days. Now, I am looking forward to perusing it. I know, I know...apparently I didn't get the "word" either about not liking book selections. Perhaps someday the pendulum will swing back the other way & VP people will drool over SL catalogs. Sigh.

~Karen~

Married for 22 years!

Homeschooling for 13 years~10 years with Sonlight!!

Dd18-12th grade & Ds15-9th grade.

 

 

My 2015 resolution word: Focus! 


#10 my cup of tea & me

    Finding my happy pace!

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 4,057 posts

Posted 23 May 2012 - 10:58 AM

This is the exact reason I do not use VP as my spine, but add VP books to SL. The VP selections are wonderful, and will be even more wonderful for early logic stage. Many of the books have very mature themes and are idle school or even high school level, especially many of the spines. By adding VP cards, historical fiction books, and even activities, I can add to the "rigor" or challenge of SL and make it fit my child. Keeping in mind, we are in the younger cores, so I have no idea what it would look like to add to the older cores, I know there is already a lot there.


Hmmm... curiouser and curiouser.

~Karen~

Married for 22 years!

Homeschooling for 13 years~10 years with Sonlight!!

Dd18-12th grade & Ds15-9th grade.

 

 

My 2015 resolution word: Focus! 


#11 TNmomma

    Proclaiming Isaiah 54:13!

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 2,482 posts
  • LocationIn the land of bookshelves.

Posted 23 May 2012 - 11:22 AM

I definitely spent more time reading that catalog than Sonlights's this year....


Me too!


Me three!!

Melissa, wife to Brett for 19 years, homeschooling momma for 10 years!
Mom to
Logan, 15~ Core 200, IEW Literary Analysis/Windows to the World, Apologia Biology, TT Algebra 2, Teen Coder Computer Programing, Guitar, and RS LA Spanish lvl2.
Eli, 9~ Core C, LA grade 3 w/readers 3, Sci C, RS Math D, AAS level 1, A Reason for Handwriting Transitions, Artistic Pursuits.
Jonas, 7~ Core C, LA 2 w/readers 2, Sci C, RS Math C, AAS level 1, A Reason for Handwriting Transitions, Artistic Pursuits

Annie Caroline, 1 :)~ walking and talking and singing!
and 5 angels in Heaven, including my sweet Jordan Grace, born still 01/97.
 


#12 Xzavan

    Counting my blessings, one by one

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 31,272 posts
  • LocationWandering Around

Posted 23 May 2012 - 11:37 AM

I'm being tempted to add in quite a few titles of my own. I've learned from experience that the full program is just a bit too much for us, but I certainly enjoy many of their selections. :D

Veronica, Wife to the Best Pastor in the World

Mother to: Vaneza, 13; Xzavier, 10; Zacarayah, 8; Eliza Beth, 7; Hozannah, 2, and Keziah, 1;

Remember that it took it a group of professionals to build the


Titanic, but a lone amateur built the Ark.

Posted Image

Posted Image


#13 squirtyninja

    New Kid on the Block

  • Registered Users
  • Pip
  • 10 posts

Posted 23 May 2012 - 12:19 PM

I agree that VP books are great. I'd just warn everyone that VP has a very specific theological leaning (and fairly extreme) and is mostly focused on Western Civ and NOT global history/cultures. Also, take a very good close look at Omnibus. Many people find the theological bias heavy enough that they find it unuseable.
Katy
Mom to my summer girls who will soon be:
E - 7 Finishing CW Primer, Singapore Math 1, Adventures in America, and a handful of AO books
S - 5 Beginning to learn to read with a smattering of things, but mostly enjoying library books and drawing
A - 2 Terrorizing her sisters between busy bags

Beginning our first year of SL in the Fall with Core B, Science B, and Grade 3 Readers/LA for the oldest!

#14 club190

    book mavin

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 1,701 posts
  • LocationThe Crossroads of America

Posted 23 May 2012 - 12:24 PM

Gingerly coming out onto the limb here...

We were Principle Approachers, truth be told, we still are, it's THAT ingrained in our thinking, but we used a number of VP titles over the years. That's the main reason why I can't buy a CORE package from SL. With the exception of 300, I have all the books already. Anyway, to make a long story short, we stuck close to the Noah Plan's recommendations year in year out until we got to high school. At that point, the Noah Plan went away from a Hebraically-centered plan where everything was integrated and into the traditional Greek-based brokenness of the academic disciplines. We didn't care for that. Fortunately, that was the year that VP unveiled Omnibus. We really enjoyed that course of study, although I have to agree that the selections are too mature for 7th graders. Doing I, II, and III for 9th, 10th, and 11th grades was more reasonable. I don't have the rest of the series though. I'm not in agreement with some classical purists who prefer the neat and tidy divisions of three complete 4 year cycles. I tend to side with those who think that logic stage fits more with the physiology of puberty and not a particular grade level. Of course, this means that you don't often get to do a solid rhetoric stage before high school is complete. Persoanllly, I'm OK with that, but I'm kind of weird as far as some of that stuff goes. If I had girls I might feel differently, but as it is, boys mature at a slower rate and thus often aren't really ready for rhetoric stage until the college years. All this is to say that we loved Omnibus, might use it again, and bought a number of books from VP over the years, although usually for different grade levels than what they slate in their catalog.

Blessings,
Chris

Wife to Jim since 1991,
Mom to:
Matthew, 23: Homeschool grad 2010, Eagle Scout, making good $ working in irrigation (making hay when the sun shines).
Andrew, 19: Given up on Physics101, finally learning to drive, doing Reading with Reason: Mega Classics (beta), and eager to graduate!
Daniel, 9: Loving lots of SL titles and lower level SL Science but not doing a core right now. Instead, taking rabbit trails, finishing IEW's PAL, RightStart Math; Bear Cub.

P.S. I'm a lousy typist so please excuse any typos you see but I missed! I really don't know how my fingers get ahead of my brain with the keyboard.


#15 Dcubed

    Living Core 5

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 7,374 posts
  • LocationShanghai

Posted 23 May 2012 - 12:42 PM

We've read many of the VP book selections and dd13 tried Omnibus I, but finds it highly annoying with the pervasive Reformed theology. And, yes, we missed hearing about other cultures since they simply aren't part of VP anywhere.

So, buy some of the books and *enjoy* :). The Omnibuses used to be on Google books, so you can get an idea (maybe) if those would work for you. We needed the actual book in hand to really see how it works. If it was more general Christian or secular, we'd absolutely love it, but as it is....
Denise
Married 25 years to wonderful dh

dd 15yo, loves to read - Core 400, Graphing workbook, Write at Home Grade 11, Spectrum Chemistry, Mr. Q's Advanced Chemistry, SL Psychology
dd 14yo, loves to draw - Keys to Geometry, Core 100, Write at Home Grade 10, Conceptual Chemistry, Learning how to draw realistically, a homemade Art History course

Also studying SAT/ACT prep, Fix-It, Dave Ramsey's Financial Peace, Art of Argument and learning Mandarin with a tutor.

#16 salsa chic

    Making Friends

  • Registered Users
  • PipPip
  • 213 posts
  • LocationThe Mitten State, USA

Posted 23 May 2012 - 02:23 PM

I love the VP catalog, too, ESPECIALLY the book descriptions. It was so nice to salivate over the books and read about them. :) Oh, Sonlight, I wish that you would rethink this. I have to carry 2 SL catalogs everywhere that I go (2010 and 2012). It's getting annoying.

As someone already stated, though, I think that I would rather use SL as our base and then add some VP books to it versus the other way.Those omnibuses have some very hard core reading. I just don't want my kids to end up hating school. However, I know that I need to be a good example and read some of that hard core reading, too, stuff that I missed out on from my public education. I can't expect my kids to read it and not me! I don't want to be a hypocrite!

Carrie

My interests: I love the Spanish language, the Hispanic culture, reading, traveling, and salsa music. Give me a free ticket to travel, and I'll have my bags packed in 5 minutes! I dearly miss Guadalajara, Mexico, where I spent 2 semesters in college.

****************************
Daughter- age 7- hybrid of SL Core C and TOG Year 2 Lower Grammar, LA 3, ETC, AAS 2, Apologia- Flying Creatures, and various Spanish workbooks
Activities- AWANA, Bible Study Fellowship, choir, HS co-op

Son- age 4- Core P4/5. He's obsessed with the alphabet and loves books!

Activities- AWANA, HS co-op


#17 dwilterd

    Happily Sonlighting since 2007!

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 6,020 posts

Posted 23 May 2012 - 02:54 PM

I love the VP catalog, too, ESPECIALLY the book descriptions. It was so nice to salivate over the books and read about them. :) Oh, Sonlight, I wish that you would rethink this. I have to carry 2 SL catalogs everywhere that I go (2010 and 2012). It's getting annoying.


Yep, I happily tossed the VP catalog into my SL bag for my dd12's ortho appt this afternoon. :read: :giggle:

Currently using Cores p4/5, B, 100, and 200

 

20222709.png

 

 


#18 mklady80

    Homeschool Mom of 3!

  • Full Forum Access
  • Pip
  • 69 posts
  • LocationOklahoma

Posted 23 May 2012 - 05:29 PM

I had never received a VP catalog before, and got this one last week, and, I'll admit, I was like all of you, drooling over book descriptions! I have never been tempted before to stray from Sonlight, but the VP catalog had me actually entertaining the idea. And it's the VP catalog I'm carrying with me everywhere to devour, I wish I could say the same about my SL catalog. :(

5th year of homeschooling! :party:
:gaming: DS 12yo- Core F, LA F, with some Excellence in Writing thrown in, Teaching Textbooks Math 6, Sequential Spelling, Mind Benders workbooks, and Khan Academy online.
:girlsigh: DD 10yo- Core D, LA D Horizons and Teaching Textbooks Math, Easy Peasy Homeschool Science, HWT, Sequential Spelling, Mind Benders workbooks, and Dance Mat Typing.
:tease: DS 7yo- Core A LA/Readers Grade 1, Horizons Math, Kahn Academy,  HWT, Sonlight Science K, Magic School Bus Episodes, Spelling City, Mind Benders workbooks,


20277220.png


#19 JenJeninGA

    Registered User, after 30 days

  • Registered Users
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 3,009 posts

Posted 23 May 2012 - 06:15 PM

I love VP. I've been known to wake up with the catalog still in my hands. I taught in a school that used tons of VP material. Oh how I loved it. I still use it. I just ignore the grades they suggest and make my on call on what's appropriate.
I wish my life had background music so I could understand what is going on!

Mommy to 5 Dears:
Mr Handsome & My Heartbeat, 11 and in 5th
My Blessing, 10 and in 4th
Tinkerbelle and Ladybug, 8 and in 2nd
My Blog: Through the Kaleidoscope

#20 Bluebirdwatcher

    Registered User, after 30 days

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPip
  • 523 posts

Posted 24 May 2012 - 06:14 AM

Book descriptions. That's all I have to say. :)

#21 calandalsmom

    Registered User, after 30 days

  • Registered Users
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 7,357 posts

Posted 24 May 2012 - 06:25 AM

I just got this for the first time and find it confusing. How many books per year??? Why?

I also dont get why you have to work your daughters so hard academically then expect them to sit at home sewing and babysitting til some man comes along and picks them (at which point they can do the scut work in his home).

Makes no sense.

The books appear to be no different than any other regular old books, most of which I read as a kid, with the addition of a lot of stuff by Wilson (who I find revolting) and a bunch of hero worship-y protestant reformation anti catholic tripe. And a strange obsession with the Von Trapp family (who I hear has converted).

Edited by calandalsmom, 24 May 2012 - 06:26 AM.

Cores:
1+2 good
3 great
4 ok
5 needed a lot of work
6 wretched

Kids almost 16, almost 13, 8.5

Augmenting Core F/ 5 for a fuller experience:
https://docs.google....L-THChDiWo/edit

#22 calandalsmom

    Registered User, after 30 days

  • Registered Users
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 7,357 posts

Posted 24 May 2012 - 08:43 AM

I do admit I got a set of 1815- modern cards from WTM sale board.;) They were only 10$ so if I find a bunch of Great Awakening smut I can afford to toss it.;) Tho really, since that period is so influential I will likely teach it. Certainly not as a positive tho. *shudder*
Cores:
1+2 good
3 great
4 ok
5 needed a lot of work
6 wretched

Kids almost 16, almost 13, 8.5

Augmenting Core F/ 5 for a fuller experience:
https://docs.google....L-THChDiWo/edit

#23 Raina3

    Homeschooling in the UP

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 1,415 posts

Posted 24 May 2012 - 03:58 PM

Wow; I guess this is what I get for posting and then disappearing! Sorry, all, we've got a newborn at home. :)

I sometimes get Veritas Press envy too. It all looks so good, so rigorous, so challenging, so rewarding....

But here's the thing I keep coming back to when I get tempted: yes, it's rigorous and challenging and (perhaps) academically superior to Sonlight. But Sonlight schedules "Mara: Daughter of the Nile" for Core G -- aimed at about 6th - 8th graders. Veritas Press has it listed in their second grade offerings.

Yes, my 7 year old could listen to me reading that book. And I could feel proud of myself for pushing her and having her "complete" such a challenging read-aloud. But for what purpose?

A. Much of the material is not appropriate for her at her age (and I say this with it being one of my very favorite books of all and a cherished memory from my childhood - but more at the Core G age than the Core B age!). It's got too many mature themes and scenes.

B. Even leaving that aside, she just wouldn't get that much out of it. All the political intrigue, etc.--- it's just too advanced developmentally for her. She wouldn't get the nuances at all, even if she understood the words.

I frequently add books to our Sonlight cores, and sometimes I use the Veritas Press catalog for ideas. Sometimes the books I add are more challenging, more demanding -- it depends on the child, his/her maturity, the topic.

But in general I trust Sonlight's selections to present new ideas to my kids, develop their listening and reading vocabulary, their comprehension and understanding -- but at in age-appropriate way. Veritas Press may challenge (or push!) but I think a lot of their titles "challenge" in a way that is more about the parent getting to feel rigorous than the child gaining meaningful knowledge.

Thank you. Your post was very helpful. The bolded part was a really good point.

Oh my goodness! I hadn't thought about that but I think that was why I actually sat and studied Veritas catalog this year and really never have in the past! I finally get to see the books and book descriptions! I definitely spent more time reading that catalog than Sonlights's this year....

Oh, I already have! I leafed through the Sonlight catalog just to see my son's picture, and haven't opened it since. I've actually perused the VP one three times in the last couple of days! It's those book descriptions that originally brought me to Sonlight, and I hadn't realized that I'd missed them so much until this catalog arrived!

I agree that VP books are great. I'd just warn everyone that VP has a very specific theological leaning (and fairly extreme) and is mostly focused on Western Civ and NOT global history/cultures. Also, take a very good close look at Omnibus. Many people find the theological bias heavy enough that they find it unuseable.

I'm definitely looking into this. I love that SL gives differing points of view on things and opens issues up to discussion. Apparently this isn't the case with VP.
Raina ~
wife to my singer, and mom to:

DS 12 (7th) ~ Core G, SL science G, Teaching Textbooks, Growing with Grammar, IEW, AAS, Typing Instructor Platinum
DD 4 (Preschool) ~ Core P3/4
DD 2 (fun) ~ books, singing, books, dolls, and more books
DS 1 (mischief) ~ everything, everyone, everywhere, all the time

#24 Kel & the kids

    My wig and I...

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 1,982 posts
  • LocationIn Canada eh!

Posted 24 May 2012 - 07:49 PM

I LOVE the VP catalogue! That said I haven't loved the resources as much as I thought I would once I've tried to use them. I do like the "Hearts and Hands" series for church history and a few other things. I pick a few of their, or Memoria Presses lit. choices per year for a challenge.

If you are considering Omnibus I highly suggest you read through the books that are assigned to go with whatever level you choose. I ordered all that I could get from the library for Omnibus I and started reading (one I remember in there was "The Twelve Caesars") and it just was *not* for us even though I was initially really excited about the Omnibus text and online course. I still think it's a great course but you really have to be comfortable with what's covered and have student for whom going into that kind of detail would be appealing.

I may use the VP history cards our next time through the ancients/middle ages. I had the ones for early N. Am. history but for us as Canadians they were a little too US focused (no kidding huh?). They are a useful tool.

I get happier with SL every year for our family as a good, solid, interesting course of study that we enjoy :)

Kel, married to Big D 17 yrs,

Combining my 3 girls in Cores G, B and C this year


Sean 15 -Computer Geek - Back for Grade 9 at home! MOH 3, SL G/H readers, Bible H, Saxon Alg1, Vocab Classical Roots A, IEW, piano, Trad. Logic 1, Fix-It! Grammar, MP Short Story, Science at school.
Jenna 13 -Sports Freak - Core G, Saxon 7/6, Fix-It! Grammar, Vocab Classical Roots 6, Easy Spanish, Abeka Sc., MP Poetry, IEW Middle Ages online, Piano, God's Perfect Plan.
Paige 9 -going on 29 - Core G/B/C, LA 4-5, R&S English 4, Rightstart Math E, Piano, Artpac 4, CLE Bible 4, Latina Christiana, Abeka Science 4, History Pockets.
Brooke 7 -YEY! Core G/B/C, LA 2/3!, Rightstart Math C!, HWOT Cursive! CLE Bible 2, Abeka Science and Phonics 2! History Pockets! *It's SO exciting to be 7!

 

 My Blog:     http://pressonandcou...joy.blogspot.ca 


#25 Merry

    Isaiah 40:11

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 28,979 posts

Posted 25 May 2012 - 09:00 PM

I love Sonlight. We're having a great time going (slowly) though Core F right now. But yesterday I received a catalog from Veritas Press for some reason, and . . . wow. I was impressed.

Yes, I'll admit that the colorful pages, the wonderful book descriptions, and the way it was all laid out turned my eye. :) But also, it really does look similar to Sonlight, with many of the books being the same, although used in a different order.

If it's not broken, don't fix it, right? I know I should stick with Sonlight because it works well for us. But still . . .

Have any of you used Veritas Press? Is it close to the Sonlight way or am I way off?


The bolded would make the decision for me! Go looking when something isn't working. Or to augment.

I don't get the VP catalog any more because I haven't ordered from them, but my friend was drooling over all the descriptions this week, plus I guess they are doing a big push to match Amazon's pricing & are advertising that.

I considered omnibus a year or two ago but just didn't find it a good fit for us. Also find VP's suggestions in general to be too much too early for us.

I'm another who is working out of two SL catalogs to figure out what to do. The new one just isn't good for much. I think this was my lowest order from SL in years. I spent more time in the old catalog and looking online, so I ended up ordering from more different places too. I'm excited about next year though!

Merry :-)

Wife to my dh (25 years!), and Mom to ds-18 and dd-16

Author: Invisible Illness, Visible God: When Pain Meets the Power of an Indestructible Life ~101 Devotions ~

All About Reading & Spelling (user, affiliate, customer service)
2014/2015: MOH IV, selections from SL 300 & 530, LLATL British Lit, Speech (local), Understanding the Times, How to Be a Superstar Student (Teaching Co.), Latitude, MUS Geometry and Stewardship, Apologia Chemistry, Irasshai Japanese, Rosetta Stone Spanish, Workboxes...and a lotta prayer!

Hope For Homeschool Blog

 

Sonlight materials used: Cores P, A, B, C, D, E, F, G, most of H, 100, and eclectic parts of 200, 300, 400, and 530, LA 3 (and tried 8 weeks of LA K & 1), and Science K, 1, 2, 5.

 

gallery_310_361_47144.jpg


#26 salsa chic

    Making Friends

  • Registered Users
  • PipPip
  • 213 posts
  • LocationThe Mitten State, USA

Posted 26 May 2012 - 07:02 AM

I'm so glad that I'm not the only one who has resorted to using 2 catalogs. The 2012 just doesn't fit my needs. It's useless most of the time.

Carrie

My interests: I love the Spanish language, the Hispanic culture, reading, traveling, and salsa music. Give me a free ticket to travel, and I'll have my bags packed in 5 minutes! I dearly miss Guadalajara, Mexico, where I spent 2 semesters in college.

****************************
Daughter- age 7- hybrid of SL Core C and TOG Year 2 Lower Grammar, LA 3, ETC, AAS 2, Apologia- Flying Creatures, and various Spanish workbooks
Activities- AWANA, Bible Study Fellowship, choir, HS co-op

Son- age 4- Core P4/5. He's obsessed with the alphabet and loves books!

Activities- AWANA, HS co-op


#27 SuzySchool

    Registered User, after 30 days

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 1,511 posts
  • Locationin the land of coffee

Posted 27 May 2012 - 07:59 PM

I sometimes get Veritas Press envy too. It all looks so good, so rigorous, so challenging, so rewarding....

But here's the thing I keep coming back to when I get tempted: yes, it's rigorous and challenging and (perhaps) academically superior to Sonlight. But Sonlight schedules "Mara: Daughter of the Nile" for Core G -- aimed at about 6th - 8th graders. Veritas Press has it listed in their second grade offerings.

Yes, my 7 year old could listen to me reading that book. And I could feel proud of myself for pushing her and having her "complete" such a challenging read-aloud. But for what purpose?

A. Much of the material is not appropriate for her at her age (and I say this with it being one of my very favorite books of all and a cherished memory from my childhood - but more at the Core G age than the Core B age!). It's got too many mature themes and scenes.

B. Even leaving that aside, she just wouldn't get that much out of it. All the political intrigue, etc.--- it's just too advanced developmentally for her. She wouldn't get the nuances at all, even if she understood the words.

I frequently add books to our Sonlight cores, and sometimes I use the Veritas Press catalog for ideas. Sometimes the books I add are more challenging, more demanding -- it depends on the child, his/her maturity, the topic.

But in general I trust Sonlight's selections to present new ideas to my kids, develop their listening and reading vocabulary, their comprehension and understanding -- but at in age-appropriate way. Veritas Press may challenge (or push!) but I think a lot of their titles "challenge" in a way that is more about the parent getting to feel rigorous than the child gaining meaningful knowledge.


WSS. VP does seem to offer many of the same books at a lower grade level. Too many for me to want to switch. But it is enticing. ;)

Susan:
wife to DH since 1995
mom to: DD since 1998, DS since 2000, DD (our sweet China baby born 2004) home since 2005 and DD since 2008

Sonlighter since the beginning! Also: MUS, Singapore Essentials, Easy Grammar, Essentials in Writing, Queen Homeschool, CurrClick Live Mandarin, CLE, Alpha Phonics, Speech Boot Camp. Not all at the same time for the same kid.


#28 Livin'inthelibrary

    Books are my decor

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 6,649 posts
  • LocationLand of 10,000 Lakes

Posted 28 May 2012 - 10:46 AM

I've used a number of their products over the years. I have all of their cards for History and Bible. I never got a catalog this year, how disappointing! I usually buy their products from Rainbow Resource or some such so I guess they figured I wasn't interested. I wouldn't use them as my main curriculum though. I disagree with their Christian doctrine, I'm of the Arminianistic persuasion not Calvinistic, thank you Core 200 for helping me figure this out!

I like some of their products but not when they schedule them. I think Sonlight's schedules are much more age appropriate. I also appreciate that Sonlight adds some fun into the schedule and not just heavy study.
Sue in MN:
My six homeschool graduates are in this picture.
I'm a college senior majoring in English.

#29 dwilterd

    Happily Sonlighting since 2007!

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 6,020 posts

Posted 28 May 2012 - 02:01 PM

I've used a number of their products over the years. I have all of their cards for History and Bible. I never got a catalog this year, how disappointing! I usually buy their products from Rainbow Resource or some such so I guess they figured I wasn't interested. I wouldn't use them as my main curriculum though. I disagree with their Christian doctrine, I'm of the Arminianistic persuasion not Calvinistic, thank you Core 200 for helping me figure this out!

I like some of their products but not when they schedule them. I think Sonlight's schedules are much more age appropriate. I also appreciate that Sonlight adds some fun into the schedule and not just heavy study.


I had no idea their products were available elsewhere! I'll have to go look since I'm stockpiling my 3rd Rainbow order right now. I really need to start school soon so I can stop curriculum shopping! SL, hurry up with that IG will ya?? lol

Currently using Cores p4/5, B, 100, and 200

 

20222709.png

 

 


#30 CrayolaMom

    We'll figure this out together!

  • Full Forum Access
  • Pip
  • 25 posts
  • LocationCT

Posted 08 April 2013 - 04:12 PM

This post has added to my curriculum addiction and my girls aren't even reading yet! Actually we aren't even doing school yet because I can't stop researching/ buying curriculum. And NOW I am drooling over VP.....the book selections.....oooooo help me. Can I start my own education from scratch? I ordered a catalog just so I could spend time looking through it - wonderful. But I do agree that it seems advanced.....
*TRACY* Part time ICU nurse, all the time homeschooling mama!!
Married to Dave <3 love of my life
Zoey Carmella age 3 *P3/4*, Timberdoodle preschool, Starfall, Outdoor Hour Challenge and Kumon/ various workbooks
Kalley Madison age 19 mos *following along*

Gretyl age 12 Mini Schnauzer


Our HS blog in progress: http://www.wesharecrayons.blogspot.com

#31 Little Women

    Love to read

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 17,422 posts
  • LocationOn my knees

Posted 08 April 2013 - 07:51 PM

I used some VP a few years ago. I found that:

They do not separate out the books that are suitable for each grade/age level. Quite a few of their "spine" books are way over grade level, even up to some adult, boring books in elementary years, and they don't label which are which. If you can't see them at the library, you have no idea what you are getting.

They don't have a schedule, or at least, they didn't when I used it. You were supposed to use the cards as reference points, then there were half a dozen resources per card, to read in whatever way you wanted.

Some of the major books seemed either dumb or boring to me. Eg, the Bible/History spine for the early grades just pretty much re-tells the Bible stories, which my kids already knew. There were some pictures of pots or whatever, but lesson after lesson about things they already knew was pointless for us.

I felt they were overly specific about some things, which I don't think we know to that degree of exactness. One of their songs to go along with the cards, eg, stated that Abraham left Ur in 2123BC (or some such date)--down to the year? I am skeptical. This annoyed me, because I felt that they were using Bible as the primary basis for history, but then going beyond what you can get directly from the Bible in assigning a specific year in this way. We did not use the songs, after that (which was, of course, the very beginning of the year.)

The additional books that are so enticing are not scheduled at all. The cards have the main spines--everything else, you pick how many, you pick which ones--easy to over- or under-buy. And the additional books are also not really separated by age level, so again, you just don't know.

I did love that they label their readers for regular or advanced readers. We used several of their advanced reading choices, and they worked very well for us. Also love the book descriptions, of course.

Melinda S.
Mom to 20yo "Meg" (college junior),  18yo "Jo" (college freshman), 14yo becoming a "Beth," 11yo "Amy"
thingslearnedthehardway@blogspot.com

 

20031774.png


#32 Sweet Tea in MD

    Eph.3:16-20

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPip
  • 326 posts

Posted 09 April 2013 - 07:29 PM

We actually used VP this year for History. My kids can sing the song easily, remember information on the cards for the most part easily, hate the format is the same every week (i.e. worksheet, resources, project, test), and asked if we could go back to Sonlight this year. They miss the fiction (even though I bought both levels of the historical fiction) and the read alouds (even though I have read aloud some of the books). It is rigorous and demands a lot of memorization --easy for some, harder for others -- I have one who memorized easily and another who struggles with it. I think they will be able to recite more history at the end of this year, but I don't think they will have enjoyed learning as much. MHO.

P.S. We are coming back to Sonlight next year.

P.S.S. I like the format of the pdf for the book list for last year better than this year's. I don't mind printing them out, and I carry yhem with my catalog, They give me more room for notes!

Edited by Sweet Tea in MD, 09 April 2013 - 07:32 PM.

Married to DH for 11 yrs, Mom to DD1 (1/2003), DD2(10/2004) and DD3 (7/2007), and driver of the get away van to all kinds of activities and playdates.

#33 MommyPenguin

    Sonlight fan

  • Full Forum Access
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 2,382 posts
  • LocationMilitary wife, so we move a lot!

Posted 09 April 2013 - 09:12 PM

I like the idea of using some of their books to supplement (I'm trying to be really careful, too, because Core B aligns with their 2nd and 3rd grade stuff, which means that some of the books are *way* too advanced, so I look up reviews on Amazon and see what ages people mention), but I prefer the structure of Sonlight, myself. With the ages of my kids, I'm not really concerned about memorization so much as getting a basic idea. My oldest is really interested in Egypt and Greece, particularly, though, so I'm planning to add in some Veritas Press books, the Hands and Hearts kits, and taking a bit longer to get through Core B. Their catalog *is* really fascinating because it has the book descriptions, though! I was so excited to receive Sonlight's and then barely ended up looking at it. I did print the book descriptions and read through them, which was interesting (although hard to read, the way it printed), but it wasn't the same. The VP catalog definitely makes me tempted to buy after reading all about those books that sound so interesting!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
-Sarah-
Emily is 8 years old (1/07), 2nd grade, and doing Core B, Apologia Botany, FLL 2, WWE 2, AAS 2, AAR 3, Singapore 2A, Life of Fred Farming, BetterChinese Mandarin, Song School Latin, Logic, ARFH T, and LEGO WeDo;
Jenny is 6 years old (10/08), kindergarten, and doing geography/world cultures, AAR 3, Singapore 1B, Logic, ARFH A, BetterChinese Mandarin, Song School Latin;
Charlotte is 4 years old (8/10), pre-k, and doing geography/world cultures, AAR 1, Mathematical Reasoning, Letter of the Week from Confessions of a Homeschooler, BetterChinese Mandarin;
Megan is 2 years old (10/12), and is a crazy climbing toddler who can scale baby gates, open childproof locks, and remove her own diaper--but who loves Elmo, Giant Penguin, and Signing Time; and

Lydia is 4 months old (12/14), and is a sweet new baby who loves sleeping all day so long as somebody holds her, and would happily live in the Ergo.
Blogging about homeschooling here!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~





0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users